1. Home
  2. ›
  3. business
  4. ›
  5. Management & Leadership
  6. ›
  7. Why your antique culture is burning your best people and your profits

Why your antique culture is burning your best people and your profits

The word ‘culture’ is a dangerous corporate sedative for most chief executives. It’s overused and – in many cases – fails to command attention. However, the best performing CEOs have taken culture out of the manila folder in HR’s filing cabinet and made it top of mind for their board, their executives and every operational leader.

Decades ago, Harvard Business School conducted research on the corporate cultures of more than 200 companies over 11 years. One of the more significant findings was that 12 firms with performance-enhancing cultures saw average share price growth of over 900 percent during that time, compared with just 74 percent on average for 20 companies without such cultures.

The truth is that the delegation of culture to HR, the underdevelopment of cultural acumen among leaders and the perpetuation of ancient practices have never been more destructive.

Let’s start with three surprising realities.

1. The lights are off, but somebody’s home.

In a study across nearly 2,000 employees and using methodology validated by the WHO, the Global Corporate Challenge found the average worker absent for about four days a year and present but functionally unproductive for almost three months. That’s 57.5 days per person producing nothing of value.

Most organizations track absenteeism through sick leave rates, absence dashboards and return to work interviews. Very few track the 57.5 days, because most cultures are set to count only who shows up.

2. Workplace sleight of hand trumps workplace science.

So many workplace practices are unproven inheritances from a bygone era. The open plan office, introduced for collaboration, has been proven to reduce satisfaction more than it improves interaction. A Harvard Business School study found that in open plan offices face-to-face collaboration decreases by around 70 percent.

Research published in the Journal of Applied Psychology found that evaluators’ individual rating tendencies accounted for up to 62 percent of the variation in employee performance ratings. Group brainstorming generates fewer ideas than the same people working alone and combining their output afterwards and return-to-office mandates drive away your most experienced people first.

3. We work five days a week because 100 years ago a guy who mass produced cars said we should.

In 1926 Henry Ford popularized the five-day week. At the time he was solving a real problem. Machines ran at a fixed rate, output was a function of hours at the station and attendance was a reasonable proxy for productivity because attendance was the only thing anyone could measure.

We work five days a week because 100 years ago a guy who mass produced cars said we should.

That constraint disappeared decades ago. The structure stayed and so did the assumption underneath it, which is that time spent is a reliable measure of value produced.

Each solution answered a question somebody was asking at the time. None was tested before it became standard and each has been repeated for a century regardless of how society moved on. Even now, in the bright light of counter evidence, very few have been retired. Sadly, this collection of untested norms is what most executives assume is best practice.

The cost of our inheritance

Most cultures are inherited and shaped by outdated assumptions. Gallup puts the global cost of burnout and disengagement above US$8.9 trillion a year, roughly nine percent of everything the world produces.

Presenteeism costs the United States economy around US$1.5 trillion a year against US$150 billion for absenteeism. Current in-office working practices cost 10 times more than people not showing up.

Burned out employees are nearly three times more likely to say they will leave within the year, and replacing them costs between 50 and 200 percent of their annual salary. Deloitte found 73 percent of Gen Z and 70 percent of Millennials considering a move are driven largely by burnout.



Advertisement

The mathematics on hours is just as unforgiving. Stanford economist John Pencavel found productivity declined sharply past 50 hours a week, and that at 70 hours total output matched what the same worker produced at 55. Those extra 15 hours produced nothing and guaranteed burnout.

If your senior team works 60-hour weeks, you are paying for two dead days per executive per week and paying again in medical claims and replacement costs.

The standard response to all of this is a wellbeing program. Remedies that treat what is very clearly a design fault (culture) as a personal failing, which is why so many organizations have concluded that culture change is futile.

AI is making the same culture faster

When it comes to burnout, AI is often an accelerant. Every productivity technology in history has been absorbed by the culture it entered and AI is following that pattern. When a tool lets someone write a report in half the time, the reward is two reports. The gain gets captured by the organization and never reaches the worker as recovery time.

When it comes to burnout, AI is often an accelerant.

The human cost is already measurable. Moodle’s 2025 research found 13 percent of United States employees reported that anxiety about AI’s impact on their role is actively driving their burnout, a stress that barely existed five years ago.

ADP’s ‘Today at Work’ 2026 report found only 19 percent of workers globally are fully engaged, with AI-driven insecurity a primary driver, and ADP’s own researchers called it a leadership failure.

Consider what that means operationally. You are asking the most stressed workforce in recorded history to absorb the largest shift in work since industrialization, using a culture built for an assembly line.

Your best people leave first

Like a match, burnout burns from the top, and the top here means potential and performance. This is the opposite of what most executive teams assume.

Burnout reaches the people who are carrying the most first. They volunteer for the difficult work, they absorb the overflow when someone resigns and they are the last to admit they are struggling because their identity is built on coping. By the time it shows in their output they’ve been alight for months, which is not an easy fire to extinguish.

Burnout reaches the people who are carrying the most first.

Unsurprisingly, the best talent is walking away from tinderbox cultures. A University of Pittsburgh study tracking more than three million employee profiles across major technology and financial firms found return-to-office mandates accelerated the departure of high-performing, senior and diverse employees at disproportionate rates. Turnover rose 13–14 percent, roles took 12 days longer to fill and financial performance did not improve.

The evidence that conditions are behind the exodus is solid. Stanford’s Nicholas Bloom ran a randomized controlled trial across 1,612 employees at Trip.com. Hybrid workers matched their peers on performance grades, promotions and code written, and were 33 percent less likely to resign.

The truth is, high performers don’t leave meaningful jobs in good cultures. They leave when they have run out of reasons to stay.

Assembly line culture doesn’t work for knowledge workers

Humans are hardwired to chase novelty and solve problems. Researchers Edward Deci and Richard Ryan established autonomy and intrinsic motivation as biological requirements rather than pleasant, static conditions, and Dan Pink named autonomy, mastery and purpose as the drivers of high performance. Nothing in that literature supports repetition at volume, which is what an assembly line culture delivers to knowledge workers.

Performance is far more valuable than compliance.

Sixty years after Ford, Cambridge neuroscientist Wolfram Schultz showed that dopamine neurons require progressively greater stimulation to produce the same reward signal. Under chronic pressure, the nervous system recalibrates upward and the habituated brain reads its own calm as deprivation, which is why rest feels threatening to the people who most need it. Performance is far more valuable than compliance.

What the best leaders do about it

The best leaders recognize that they were never trained in shaping culture, so they start testing and learning.

In August 2019, Microsoft Japan closed its offices every Friday for a month, giving 2,300 employees a paid day off. Productivity rose 39.9 percent against the same month a year earlier and 92.1 percent of employees were satisfied with the arrangement, in one of the most overworked corporate cultures on Earth.

Between June and December 2022, 61 companies and around 2,900 employees in the United Kingdom ran the largest coordinated trial of reduced hours yet attempted, researched by Cambridge and Boston College with 4 Day Week Global and Autonomy. The results showed 71 percent of employees reported lower burnout. Revenue rose 1.4 percent. Staff turnover fell by 57 percent and sick days fell by 65 percent. Fifty-six of the 61 companies carried on after the trial was complete.

A 57 percent reduction in turnover is an enormous saving, and it protects the people you can least afford to lose.

None of this requires you to adopt a four-day week. That idea is so challenging for most CEOs that they stop seeing the performance and shareholder value underneath it. Better CEOs reshape culture in line with evidence rather than convenience. Repeating the patterns of the past is convenient and 100 years on, it is rarely the best option.

Henry Ford could count hours and nothing else. You have instruments he never had and you are probably still running a culture built around his constraint without knowing it. Be careful you’re not building to burn, and burning more than your people.

Where to start on Monday

  1. Measure the health of your culture, not just the engagement of your people. Employees can be highly engaged inside the suboptimal cultures of the past.
  2. Watch who is leaving, not how many. Voluntary departures among high performers are the loudest signal your organization will send you. Track the composition of your attrition rather than the percentage.
  3. Audit one inherited practice a quarter. Pick the annual review, the standing meeting, the open-plan floor or the hours and ask what evidence supports it. You’ll be surprised.
  4. Return some of the AI gain to the people producing it. If a team’s output doubles, decide how much becomes recovery rather than letting it all become expectation.
  5. Train your leaders to shape culture. According to research, 82 percent of managers in the United Kingdom entered management with no formal leadership training of any kind. Those that do are taught to run a team rather than to design the conditions that team works in, which is where employee, customer and commercial needs meet.

Opinions expressed by The CEO Magazine contributors are their own.
Inspiring The Business World